marvelstudios

Why Pedro is actually very well cast as Reed

Why Pedro is actually very well cast as Reed

The casting of Pedro Pascal as Reed Richards has caused tons of controversy. The prevailing theory seems to be that Marvel only cast him because of his rising popularity and not because he's the right fit for the role, but I actually think it was a brilliant decision.

The criteria for casting Reed was bigger and more complicated than probably any other character they've ever cast before. They needed to find an actor who...

  • Is a big enough name to draw attention (the Valentine's Day announcement would have meant nothing if it was just a random unknown actor)
  • Has tons of charisma with those around them
  • Can easily fit into the 1960s setting
  • Can easily fit into a modern setting
  • Has enough range to play the different sides of Reed (obsessive scientist, loving family man, iconic superhero)
  • Is old enough to convincingly play an aging scientist/father but also be young enough to carry a franchise for 10-15 years
  • Is no stranger to big franchises but also isn't too busy that they can't keep showing up for more movies

When you look at the criteria, casting Pedro Pascal suddenly makes a ton of sense. Unlike the silly fancastings that only ever focus on superficial elements, the studio has to take it ALL into consideration. They can't just cast a random, unknown actor who looks like Reed from that one comic panel. They need to make sure the actor they hire ticks all the boxes, and I believe Pedro does that.

https://i.redd.it/3zldr55uoubf1.png
Reddit

Discussion

furryfriend77

Sure beats how they wasted him in the DC universe.

16 hours ago
Legoman8D

who does pedro play in dc??

14 hours ago
No_Temporary2732

Maxwell Lord in "Wonder Woman and the very dubious and immoral way of bringing back your boyfriend in 1984"

13 hours ago
Nyctoz

You need to give me the stone.

9 hours ago
furryfriend77

5 hours ago
Legoman8D

would. next

4 hours ago
furryfriend77

4 hours ago
GhandisFlipFlop

wood. next

4 hours ago
furryfriend77

4 hours ago
Mrcoolyp1234

John Favreau : "Choking me with your legs was necessary."

3 hours ago
Altruistic-Rice5514

would, next.

3 hours ago
TheInvisibleCircus
Peggy Carter

Yew neeed to gev me thr stawrn

2 hours ago
kellial

Underrated title 🤣🤣🤣

9 hours ago
Lawgamer411

Not to mention when Wonder Woman rapes a guy

7 hours ago
Insane_Masturbator69

Not only raping, later she even met him and smiled to him while he had no clue what happened. Imagine you chilling around, not knowing who raped you was right there looking at you and smiled thinking about the "good" memories with your body. Holy Jesus, they actually wrote it ...

6 hours ago
cowboynoodless
Matt Murdock

She did what now

5 hours ago
Disastrous_Study7733

Yeah man. Her boyfriend stole a random guy's body, they make fun of him and commit a bunch of crimes together and then she rapes the guys body.

4 hours ago
kenba2099
M'Baku

I mean to be fair the actress is very used to committing crimes.

3 hours ago
yanray

War crimes, no less

2 hours ago
Sarahthelizard
Peggy Carter

I think it was the writing plus the overall plot, he came to work for that one.

4 hours ago
ryanpm40

Lmao great description. Man that drop in quality between movies was worse than Raimi's Spider-Man 2 to 3

6 hours ago
funkypepermint

He played the villian in wonder woman 84

13 hours ago
Legoman8D

oh ye. i forgot lol

13 hours ago
Baronheisenberg

It was so bad, it also made me forget Wonder Womans 2 through 83.

2 hours ago
Manticore416

I think most of us forgot everything about that awful movie

13 hours ago
Oopsiedazy

They made a movie set in the 80s, and despite Warner Bros owning the rights to roughly 1/3 of the music ever made they made the baffling choice to not have the soundtrack be a selection of the best songs from that decade. That movie would still have been terrible if they’d licenced some bangers, but it would have been FUN terrible. James Gunn came in too late, he would never have let that movie open without a mixtape.

9 hours ago
Bruhimonlyeleven

Agreed. Look what stranger things did for running up that hill, and Gunn did for Fleetwood Mac. There are so many 80s bangers that would have fit perfectly, it's a shame they didn't use anything.

I wonder if the new Superman has music in it? It might feel off with superman, orchestraesque music nigtht be the better call, with maybe a single song or two outside it.

7 hours ago
bolerobell

It’s got some punk music. Quite a bit actually.

4 hours ago
buzzedewok

Jenkins really dropped the ball on that movie.

4 hours ago
Oopsiedazy

As did every producer and writer. And DC execs had a habit of mangling movies in the editing room. Hopefully Gunn will be able to exert some control and/or show restraint.

3 hours ago
Cymen90

He is the "That's good but it could be better" meme

7 hours ago
theodo
Ant-Man

That's what happens when you don't let him keep the stache

9 hours ago
furryfriend77

9 hours ago
Citizensnnippss

Pedro is hated because he's popular and popular because he's beloved.

Strange situation with him.

Personally, I love him.

16 hours ago
BurcoPresentsHisAcc

Every famous person has haters. The more the fans, the more haters.

16 hours ago
HyperlinksAwakening

They hate us because they... anus?

16 hours ago
SvenXavierAlexander

They hate us cause they Thanus.

12 hours ago
Grabs_Zel

That one Ant-Man victory scenario Dr. Strange chose to ignore...

9 hours ago
MoarFurLess

Wrecked ‘em. 

16 hours ago
pink_goon

Rectum? Damn near killed 'em.

13 hours ago
goterr

Wrecked they're rectums?

16 hours ago
Legoman8D

THEY HATE US BECAUSE THEY AINT US!!!

14 hours ago
Ivan_Redditor
Danny Rand

The fuck does anus have to do with any of this?

15 hours ago
Key-Specific-4368

Everyone has one

6 hours ago
EdmundtheMartyr

Yeah. I have zero haters amongst film fans. But that’s because I’m an accountant who’s never acted in a single movie.

10 hours ago
AChineseSpyBalloon

He also just seems to be a genuinely kind & authentic person, and carries the level of confidence that comes with that. That pisses off anonymous internet trolls who wish they felt the same way about themselves.

16 hours ago
SoylentCreek

He’s not even really hated. This is just Reddit doing its thing, just like they did with Jennifer Lawrence, Chris Pratt, Ryan Reynolds, and a host of other celebrities that exploded in popularity. The man is a good actor with a ton of range, works his ass off, and is getting his bag. Respect.

16 hours ago
pls_coach_me_Timmy

Oh Pedro surely is a beloved actor. But he is also proportionally overhated as a result of right wing social media outlets doing their thing. The youtube algorithm is a hate fueling motor that attacks any actor who openly advocates for immigrant rights and supports queerness. His current exposure makes him an easy target.

1 hour ago
ScoobyDeezy
Fitz

Okay but Chris Pratt was shoe-horned by Hollywood into every single project ever regardless of whether he was right for the role or not.

The hate is misdirected, but appropriate.

13 hours ago
Zrex_9224

Part of Pratt's hatred also came about because of his religious views and his church's support of anti-LGBTQ policies and organizations.

2 hours ago
TommyCrump92

Yeah I don't get the hate, most people wanna hate him because they're bigots towards his opinions and because his sister being trans like its ridiculous just let people exist and find a better reason to dislike someone regardless of their political opinions or rather an opinion that is letting a community exist

10 hours ago
Kathrynlena

Everything I learn about him as a person makes me love him more. He seems like a genuinely good person. He’s also an amazing actor and I love his work.

12 hours ago
ArchdruidHalsin

He's insanely talented and, from what I can tell, a super kind dude. Especially in this industry, that's the kind of guy I'm always happy to see getting work.

That being said, as an indie filmmaker, I do kind of hate the oversaturation of any one particular actor in the market, regardless of talent. It often has nothing to do with that performer, but moreso the executive thinking behind it.

It's like how after the Dark Knight, everything had to get a "dark and gritty reboot". Chris Pratt and JLaw were everywhere for awhile. Zombie fad. Multiverse fad.

To me, it's indicative of a lot of projects being put together as marketing packages before a script is even there. Some suit says "Oh, this is a popular IP and popular actor. I can sell that, let's greenlight and announce. Find me a cheap writer and set a deadline." All this rather than the script informing when a project is ready. I've at least been pretty encouraged by James Gunn's quotes about taking the latter approach with DC, which shows a bit of restraint.

It also starts to challenge my immersion. There is no shortage of talent, and the top tier actors are way overpayed while many struggle to make ends meet. I wish there was more the union could do to remedy this, but so much of the economics surrounding the industry depends on "celebrity culture". Not sure there's a way to change things. But I'd like to see a lot more variety on my screens and know a lot less about who they are IRL, personally.

15 hours ago
Bazonkawomp

I don’t understand why someone getting a lot of work is over saturation. I would think surely as a filmmaker you’d understand making it that far in your career and taking all the big work you can.

13 hours ago
Purple-Mix1033

He has his strengths and weaknesses as an actor. I think certain colors are more in his range. I liked him a lot in that nic cage movie as well as his GoT character.

I was concerned about his ability to take on Reed but I think he’ll be good.

16 hours ago
Bazonkawomp

May I ask what is so special about Reed that you’d assume an accomplished actor couldn’t portray him? I don’t understand this sentiment when I read it about this character.

13 hours ago
Purple-Mix1033

Hyper-intelligence, slight arrogance, some warmth and some aloofness, some passion

There’s a dichotomy there and there’s levels to the character. I don’t think it’s easy to pull off. I haven’t seen all these qualities from Pedro before but I’m open to his casting and looking forward to his performance

13 hours ago
MooseMan12992

It's so funny and weird hearing grown men act like catty high school girls saying "he doesn't look right" "eww he's too old" "eww he's not even white" its fucking pathetic

14 hours ago
Pristine-Passage-100

It’s not about hating him. I love him and think he’s a phenomenal actor, but I think he was miscast here.

16 hours ago
jetlaggedandhungry

To be fair, lots of people initially thought Heath Ledger was a miscast as the Joker (myself included) until the movie came out.

Does Pedro seem like the obvious casting choice for Reed? I wouldn't say so; however, I've been delightfully surprised before and hope I am delightfully surprised again when it comes to casting picks.

7 hours ago
Double-Slowpoke

I’ll withhold judgment until we actually see the movie and not a bunch of trailers. Marvel is very well known for knocking trailers out of the park, even when the movie itself is mid.

I think it’s a fair criticism to say that Pascal is in too many things that appeal to the same audience: GoT, Mandolorian, Wonder Woman, Gladiator 2, Last of Us, Fantastic Four…

14 hours ago
TheMurmuring

Yeah, you can say a role is bad without disliking the actor. That's infantilizing the whole casting industry.

16 hours ago
RoddRoward

You could say that with any popular celebrity but it doesn't always work out that way

14 hours ago
IcedCheese

Everytime I see him cast in something im like "Really?!?!? Him AGAIN???. And then I watch the damn thing and remember he's at the top of his game lol.

8 hours ago
C0nstruct37

No the Strange situation is Cumberbatch. 🙂

6 hours ago
Markus2822

I LOVE him I just don’t think he’s the best fit for Reed.

It’s like if I had Ryan Reynolds I wouldn’t cast him as thor because that’s just a bad fit.

This fit isn’t bad, just not the best it could be

13 hours ago
Gr0kthis

Nobody hates Pedro. Quit being hyperbolic. Why do people take every criticism as hate? Most people love Pedro but some are getting a little tired of seeing him in every franchise out there.

We can like Pedro and still have criticisms about him.

16 hours ago
Parodon
Vision

"Getting tired of seeing him" is not fucking criticism.

13 hours ago
TheMurmuring

I love him too, but he has an undeniable warmth to him that just doesn't sit right for Reed's often cold, logic-driven character.

16 hours ago
haizydaizy

Reed has a warmth to him too. Especially with his family, when theres no impending Doom. In these cases he's such an adorable dork. But if there's a world-threatening crisis? He'll lock himself in his lab for weeks and listen to no one because his logical conclusion is the only way.

When he's spending time with his family with no terrifying crisis, or no Victor taunting him, cold isn't the word I would use for him. I'd call him a doof.

Having an actor who can handle the warm goofy side and the cold and calculated side is important, and I think Pedro can handle both from his previous acting credits.

11 hours ago
alex494

Reed is also a family man and a good friend to his team so he has those aspects sometimes.

14 hours ago
AlgerianTrash

Except Reed isn't cold and logic driven unless you're using Civil War as a reference

10 hours ago
Melodic-Cycle3994

Yeah and I feel like this will be part of the story too. I feel like with the trailers focusing more on them public personas that he will be more cold and logic driven for the public but will show warmth behind closed doors with his wife.

I feel like a detached cold dad is a hard sell for a movie franchise that is supposed to focus so much around family in 2025

15 hours ago
Creepy_Living_8733

Marvel rarely actually misses with their casting

17 hours ago
originalchaosinabox

Sarah Halley Finn, Marvel's casting director, has long been described as their "secret weapon."

12 hours ago
supercalifragilism

Very much so- the only real misstep was Kang and that wasn't bad casting, it was bad behavior on the actor's part.

16 hours ago
BleekerTheBard

Majors was fantastic casting and then he blew his career up right as it was about to truly skyrocket

16 hours ago
TheMurmuring

Yeah seriously. A whole series of films with and about Kang could have been an awesome way to keep the Marvel fire burning after the Infinity War series. Great continuity potential along the same lines. Too bad he had to be a jerk and screw it up.

16 hours ago
wiifan55

The Kang/multiverse plot wasn't landing with audiences even before Majors fucked it up. If anything, he helped Marvel get a clean break to pivot around Doom.

16 hours ago
TheMurmuring

Eh, what's popular doesn't necessarily mean good. I enjoyed the Kangs from the Loki series. The Kang from Quantumania was kind of meh.

15 hours ago
darealRockfield

What bums me out though is as far as we know, they don’t have any intention on closing the Kang stuff. I get he was found to be shitty, it was a shame honestly. However, the fact they’ll just ignore that is a shame because you would think it would be better off to finish it. I heard once his contract had it so he would be all the variants so maybe that’s why they didn’t do anything more.

5 hours ago
RepresentativeAge444

AQ really wasted the character. Introducing him in an Antman movie where he gets defeated- by Antman is not a good way to bring in your new Thanos level threat. Misstep

3 hours ago
Manticore416

Agreed. Lovecraft Country convinced me he was a future A lister. A shame he's a crappy person.

13 hours ago
DepressedArgentinian

Sarah Haley Finn, the MCU's unsung hero

13 hours ago
kazaam2244

Literally the only one I ever felt was miscast is Liv Tyler as Betty Ross, but that's such a non-issue to me that I still consider Marvel's casting record unblemished. Hell, I would've been fine if Terrance Howard stuck around as War Machine.

15 hours ago
LeoNickle

At the time I liked Terrence Howard as war machine, but he has gone off the rails since then.

13 hours ago
12InchCunt

Yea but it’s liv tyler 

10 hours ago
kazaam2244

Her name is Arwen Undómiel, you uncultured swine.

/s

4 hours ago
Vinnie_Vegas

That movie was made by Universal before Marvel Studios was even owned by Disney.

It didn't have the Marvel machine behind it.

3 hours ago
Ardyn3

i can never see why people heavily value looks over actual acting,

reed as character is a complex one.

i think pedro got the chops to do it.

and based on the trailer he's been nailing the guilt ridden shriveled reed

16 hours ago
fadetoblack237

He nailed Joel and there were similar criticisms.

13 hours ago
AVeryRipeBanana

I feel like nobody is even saying “I just can’t see him playing Reed” it’s all just “I’m sick of him” or, you know, the other stuff.

11 hours ago
goatjugsoup

Maybe they'd prefer jack black... or Tom holland

10 hours ago
nordlysbaies

That, and also saying that what he seems like irl is different from how they envision Reed’s personality and so he wouldn’t be able to be Reed, like not seeming calculating or cold or intelligent enough.

I know the franchise doesn’t exactly call for Oscar caliber acting but at the end of the day, he’s an actor and will act. He’s nailed every role he’s had so far, this wouldn’t be any different, so where is that concern really from?

8 hours ago
Doc_ET
Ultron

I'm sure he'll be great in the role, I just wish he'd shaved his mustache. Reed either needs a full beard like in the more recent comics or to be clean shaven like he usually is.

13 hours ago
PeacefulHavoc

This. Absolutely this. The mustache is a Pascal trademark, it would help distance the actor from the character. And it's not like he looks too weird, we've seen him without it already.

But idk, he shaved for WW84 and it was what it was... maybe it's just superstition at this point.

6 hours ago
Krorhodium

He can’t grow a full beard, they tried it in Game of Thrones and they decided to go with what he has instead of using a fake full beard. I don’t think facial hair makes the character, I mean Hugh Jackman is tall and not as harry as Logan in the comics, I mean in some movies he had zero hair on his torso and chest.

Pedro Pascal can be a cold hearted asshole know it all, because he’s a great actor. He’s going to be perfect.

6 hours ago
Poptotum

Respectfully disagree. Given the period and aesthetic I like the decision. When they eventually end up in the “sacred timeline” 60+ years later, I hope it’s shaved.

3 hours ago
Diortheking

Face and look wise no one has beaten grufford he looks like comic reed

16 hours ago
TheMurmuring

He can play a similar personality to Reed, too; he's been typecast along those lines as an academic, a scientist, a doctor.

16 hours ago
TeoSan2812

In a world where Jeffrey Wright is playing an amazing Jim Gordon I think we can acknowledge that similar looks are not a requirement

14 hours ago
RadioBitter3461

My brother was furious about this and I asked him what part of Gordon’s character has his skin Color embedded in it?

13 hours ago
BigBlue1105

This! Looks aren’t important. Acting chops are. Pedro is gonna kill it

13 hours ago
Similar_Actuary_845

Gruffudd is his name. You're right about the rest.

10 hours ago
Manticore416

Hiring someone because their face looks like the comic character would be such a dumb decision

13 hours ago
KwisatzHaderach94

they're going to start drawing comic reed with a 'stache now 😄

15 hours ago
VitiDMan

But he has been stuck with a beard for more than 10 years

15 hours ago
May_of_Teck

Suppose he’ll have to shave

15 hours ago
Choso125

He'll get his moustache for a year or two until like Mephisto will force him to shave or sometimes. Gotta keep that status quo

15 hours ago
Frequent-Maybe1243

Okay, but they should hire good actors for film roles. Not lookalikes.

12 hours ago
Forsaken_Ad7090

Gruffudd is a good actor and could've been a good Mr. Fantastic, but his films' writing failed him.

10 hours ago
Scuty1704

Yes I can agree with choosing him for popularity, that's because of Robert Downey Jr. Dr Doom and Mister Fantastic are equally major roles. To match Robert Downey Jr, Pedro is the best Reed.

16 hours ago
Rocketeer1019

Not my choice but I’m sure he’ll do a great job

Dennis from always sunny looks like the perfect reed casting to me

16 hours ago
ComoEstanBitches

The cast of IASIP is the best incarnation of the fantastic four if they weren’t already typecast by the fans and I mean that in the most serious way. Dennis Reed, Dee as Invisible Woman, Mac as Flamer On, Frank as the Thing, and Charlie as Doc Doom. They all have the acting chops to play those characters to a T

10 hours ago
HowDoIRedditGood

I would preorder tickets to this movie so fast. It would be ridiculous and perfect

3 hours ago
Upset_Dust_8494

He is incredibly talented, and I love some of his works, but when I think Reed Richards, I don't see Pedro Pascal.

7 hours ago
[deleted]

You haven't even seen the movie yet lmfao

16 hours ago
RefinedBean

I think he was a great casting and I'm excited for him in the role. Reed has a lot of subtlety to his character - absolute ego being clawed back via duty to his family, to humanity, to the universe. LITERALLY being the smartest person in any room leads to complexities that are hard for any actor to portray, and I think he can nail that.

My fan cast that I still think would be actually perfect was Penn Badgley from You, but that just wouldn't be as big of a name, and he may not have the chops, who knows.

16 hours ago
funishin

Penn would have been such an interesting choice. I think he’s an incredible actor

16 hours ago
Phiyaboi

Love the actor, interested in the movie...so its nothing personal when I say Pedro just has a "dour" countenance that doesn't remind me of comic Reed🤷🏽‍♂️

12 hours ago
Sharkfowl
Captain America

I just want him to shave

9 hours ago
Ruve06
Daredevil

Ioan Gruffodd will forever be the perfect casting for Reed, and I wish they could've cast him in the MCU. He's not even that much older than Pedro Pascal.

16 hours ago
JackIrishJack

Especialy if they are coming from another universe anyways, just bring them from the fox universe, but i am still up for Pedro

15 hours ago
Forsaken_Ad7090

It's a shame, because in a parallel world, those 2000s movies could've been great, and Gruffudd could've been to Reed, what Maguire was to Spider-Man.

16 hours ago
Ardyn3

might be a perfect looks reed.

but the movies writing failed him

16 hours ago
ProbablyFear

Did you use AI for this post?…

14 hours ago
spartakooky

It feels that way

The prevailing theory seems to be that Marvel only cast him because of his rising popularity

And then the first point is

They needed to find an actor who... Is a big enough name to draw attention

10 hours ago
Ragnarok_619
Spider-Man

The amount of posts defending this casting is more than the amount of hate i have seen for it.

Personally, I think they nailed the casting of 2/4 members of the Fantastic Family. Pedro and Quinn are the two that I have my doubt at. And it's not about the casting themselves, but the care that has been put into their appearance. Pedro looks like he's hopping from set to set, and that's why he has to keep that beard moustache. Quinn's hairstyle is just atrocious, you cannot defend that.

I generally don't agree with the comic accuracy bull$#/t, so i have my hopes up, expectations down.

13 hours ago
DoNotLookUp3

Quinn's hairstyle is just atrocious, you cannot defend that.

Yeah, not a fan and while I like Quinn, he doesn't really seem like a cocky hotshot the way I'd expect Johnny Storm to be.

Still, I'm very excited and hope I'm proven wrong. I can overlook the hair and having a hard time seeing Mr. Fantastic past Pedro due to his recent prevalence if the movie is good.

9 hours ago
Ragnarok_619
Spider-Man

8 billion people, and the most famous franchise cannot find some decent stylists for these actors.

9 hours ago
delonejuanderer

I dont see it at all. I don't mind the guy I just dont see it.

10 hours ago
DriveFormer8577

I could love this movie and STILL not see him as Reed.

7 hours ago
dffttffffvhg

Should at least have grown his beard all out or shaved it all off

10 hours ago
Bwc420_

stfu

14 hours ago
SevenHunnet3Hi5s

he 100% has all the acting chops and abilities to play reed. there’s just two things that he can’t control and that’s his voice and how he looks. many fans are just so used to seeing the skinny, squeaky voiced reed.

16 hours ago
Immediate_Purple3039

Except reed has never been squeaky voiced. He's always had the leave it to beaver dad tone of almost monotone but with a hint of whatever emotion fits the situation. That's how he was described by his creator anyhow.

16 hours ago
TheMurmuring

Yeah I picture him as a 50s dad smoking a pipe and teaching his kids to painstakingly construct a soap box racer in a squeaky-clean garage.

16 hours ago
Immediate_Purple3039

Exactly!

16 hours ago
PurpleTrip4654

I think he should have the tone of that one high school teacher who had to wake up early and is clearly not happy about that

15 hours ago
Main-Club-7668

I don’t care much about his voice but holy crap he looks like the same person in every movie, just wearing different clothes. One of the same issues I had with the rock, he’s the same guy in every movie. Now Pedro isn’t as bad but still. Change it up a bit, shave the mustache, flip the hair the other way, cut it, let it grow, bulk up, do something, it just seems lazy.

Oh and he’s a little weird about woman’s fingernails but that’s a whole different topic lol

16 hours ago
Ghanaguy404error

Yes that’s essentially my ONLY issue with him. He doesn’t change up his appearance and I don’t know why. Shave the mustache or go full beard for Reed. I don’t get it.

16 hours ago
Trylena
Bucky

He has shaved and change his appearance for movies, I don't think in this case it would fit the character.

And he likes nails, its an art tbh.

15 hours ago
jhorsley23

My only issue with this casting is my own personal hang up with it. At this point Pedro Pascal is the face of so many franchises that when I see him in the marketing for this movie I don’t see Reed Richards. I just see the Fantastic Four and Pedro Pascal.

I’m guessing that will fall away for me though as soon as the movie starts. Pedro is a great actor and I’ve like him in everything I’ve seen him in. I’m sure this will be do different and it’s just a little cognitive dissonance going on for me right now.

15 hours ago
12345Iamthegreatest

Not a fan of stache for me fantastic, that’s my only critique.

11 hours ago
Zestyclose-Tomato998

Do you think they asked him to shave for the role and he said the mustache has to stay? I like it. It just doesn’t fit Reed

10 hours ago
1UPZ__

Ironically Benedict would have been a better Reed and Benjamin Bratt would have been also a decent Doctor Strange. But Benedict is a chameleon type actor so he suits many characters.

9 hours ago
Mobile_Act_6091

Pedro isn’t a bad actor but he’s not the best actor for all the roles he’s been getting. I don’t think he’ll be a great reed richards, there were better options. Doesn’t mean his interpretation is going to be bad, but it won’t be a good fit for him imo. I didn’t even like him as Joel either.

16 hours ago
Techno_Core

I have no problem with him being cast as Reed, I'm personally just tired of seeing him in everything. It makes it harder for me to accept him in any role. He's more Pedro Pascal than any character he portrays.

17 hours ago
Kataratz

He's just not ... nerdy to me

12 hours ago
funishin

I’m tired of seeing that man

16 hours ago
Pristine-Passage-100

It’s not good casting when people have to make posts like this.

16 hours ago
RealWonderGal

Pure facts. Word

12 hours ago
PhotoBonjour_bombs19

Where were you when the Pedro hate was high

16 hours ago
DragonKing0203

Listen he’s a great actor and all that but he just don’t look like Reed to me. He seems too stocky to play a man with stretchy powers and it seems a lil goofy to me.

I’ll have to see how it looks on the big screen.

15 hours ago
Hobak56

I think its generally odd when people want the actors to look exactly like the comic counter part. See the fancasts just going for direct lookalike but they have no previous acting experience related to it

Pedro is a phenomenal actor with so much experience in the fiction genre and playing the smart and calculated hero. Idk why the fans aren't excited to have someone who regularly leads franchises with lure acting chops and star power

16 hours ago
redditaccount300000

An he has ability to bring levity which might be needed in a more family oriented team/movie. I never pictured him as Mr fantastic but I think he’ll be…fantastic.

16 hours ago
Hobak56

Say that again

16 hours ago
[deleted]

Because comic book fans want to see a comic accurate Reed. Adapting a comic is one thing, but how many small changes are made before that adaptation doesn't really feel like the mainstream product anymore?

This movie isn't doing a terrible job with that, but all I hear, see, perceive, is Pedro. I do not see Reed at all.

Personally, I do feel like if they shaved his face and gave him white hair on the sides it would not be a major issue. But i will see the movie and see how I feel after.

16 hours ago
Pr0xyWarrior

As a comic fan, I don’t know if I agree with all of that. Which adaptation? Which Reed? Which artist - Kirby, Buscema, Perez? I don’t know how hung up on looks and aesthetics I want to get if the person inhabiting the role can convey the character. I personally haven’t had an issue with Pedro in any of the roles he’s been in; I haven’t seen Pedro Pascal any more than I’ve seen other ‘big’ name actors in their respective roles, provides they’re one of the ones who can actually act. As long as Pedro can act like Reed, he can rock a pencil-stache and shave his head bald for all I care.

15 hours ago
Hobak56

Chris pratt playing starlord

Evans as cap

Hemsworth as Thor

All did not look like their comic counterpart.

More extremely, peggy carter played by Haley. Completely different yet very good character

Hugh Jackman as wolverine. Literally one of the best and most beloved x-men brought to live action. Speaking of Michael Fassbender as magneto.

Im sure all of these casts were hated on by people like you beforehand, but it all comes down the writing. Idk about you but I see Reed in Pedro bc ik his acting ability can do it

16 hours ago
[deleted]

We shall see

16 hours ago
Feahnor

I’m tired of seeing pascal everywhere. And also the moustache needs to go, I can only see Pedro pascal, not the character.

16 hours ago
darqy101

Nah, I still don't like him as Reed. Bad casting is bad. Johnny actor, with the bad blonde hair dye job, also looks weird imo.

16 hours ago
SunforDeiti

And The Thing not even having a thick new york accent is bad too 

14 hours ago
juanuha

Nope, no DD or opinion will change my mind on this. He is not the right cast ( and I do love Pedro ).

13 hours ago
Gregagonation

I was really hoping that they'd cast Brandon Routh instead.

16 hours ago
drstrangelove75

I feel like Brandon Routh has a stronger future at DC if he ends up cast there. He already has history with the company and hasn’t had trouble filling different characters, even in the same continuity.

14 hours ago
funkypepermint

You can white knight for internet daddy all you want. Pedro was a shit choice and is relying on money grab rationalization to prop him up

14 hours ago
AsherthonX

I think Afleck got more hate when he got cast as Batman. I’m even old enough to remember Micheal Keaton being cast. He didn’t have it easy too, and this was before the internet even. So that meant he got bad mouthed on TV and Radio.

This time around it’s amidst a giant culture war.

16 hours ago
Swimming_Warthog_745

I dont hate the casting. But I've always wanted Brandon Routh, Jake Gyllenhaal as Reed Richards 😭

16 hours ago
El_Quetzal
Stan Lee

I dont hate pedro pascal, i would love him in the mcu, but as anyone else but reed  Him and sue storm as not well cast in this film

16 hours ago
Sncrsly

Pedro is a great actor, but that doesn't make him the best for the role. Krasinski would have been better. MoM is an unfair representation of what he could have brought to the role due to the poor writing of the characters in general

15 hours ago
Strong_Yam_8978

I’m kind of tired of the narrative of having to defend everything. Pedro is a great actor and nobody doubts that. However, he is a terrible casting for a Reed Richard’s and this decision was done to purely put butts into seats based on actor popularity. And if you want proof that the MCU relies on this narrative, just look at how thunderbolts performed in the box office.

He will probably do a good enough job in the film. But he’s still not a good choice for Reed. There’s 0 resemblance to Reed.

16 hours ago
RecommendationFew466
Rocket

Who cares what he looks like? As long as he can deliver a good performance then why does it matter so much?

15 hours ago
Strong_Yam_8978

Because if you’re going to adapt Reed Richards into live action maybe the actor should actually look like Reed?

Is this a hot take or something? Why does this need to be asked, is it asking for too much? It’s almost like these films are based on some kind of original source material that’s been the standard for decades.

You can act as well as you can but if you don’t remotely look like the character you’re acting as it’s not a good casting. Simple as that.

15 hours ago
Trylena
Bucky

The best adaptation have good actors, not people that just look like the character.

14 hours ago
RecommendationFew466
Rocket

Cool beans. So define what it is to “look” like Reed Richards. Because comic book reed has had like forty different faces depending on whoever’s drawing him. Sometimes he looks whitebread boring, other times he has a whole beard. Nobody’s sitting up here saying casting should be the most random thing ever—you wouldn’t cast Danny DeVito as Superman, but prioritizing presence and performance over carbon copy appearances is just how adaptions work. Hugh Jackman is too tall and not hairy enough to be Wolverine, but that didn’t stop him from becoming THE wolverine for an entire generation of fans. Prior to 2008, Robert Downey Jr looked absolutely nothing like Iron Man. He was short and actually older than he was in the books, and again, he ended up being the definitive version of Iron Man for most people. You think Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield, or Tom Holland look anything like comic book Peter Parker? Nope. But they’re still beloved.

Those aren’t bad casting decisions. The point of casting a character is to embody the spirit of who they are in the books. Pedro Pascal has the genuine talent to sell the best and worst of Reed, and from what we’ve seen so far he’s done exactly that. If you care more about how someone looks compared to a drawing, I have some great cosplay pages for you to follow.

15 hours ago
Zealousideal_Sea8123

I'm genuinely so tired of seeing the same 5 faces everywhere I look

16 hours ago
Ausbel12

I can't wait to see how his performance goes

16 hours ago
tomclarkpods

I think he is. But if he’s not, that’s okay too. I like him either way.

16 hours ago
DunderMifflinBuffalo

I never seen him in anything until I just materialist and he wasn't that great. But I never heard of most the actors the MCU hires and most of them are good.

16 hours ago
uucchhiihhaa

Just go and watch the movie if you want to. Guy can act and I’ll enjoy the movie if it’s good. Also, what a month for cinema lovers, watched f1 on IMAX, Jurassic something and still 2 blockbusters to look forward to. Let’s go!!

16 hours ago
khushvendra

4th pic is actually fire 🔥

16 hours ago
bondinferno

Pedro is well cast in pretty much anything

16 hours ago
Dorkseid1687

Guys what ever the movie is like , Pedro will be great

15 hours ago
Arealperson_1

Plot twist: Hes not.

15 hours ago
ajver19

It's because he's a good actor.

That's it, that's all that needs to be said.

15 hours ago
MysteriousEssay5709

Honestly, he was a good choice. It’s not easy to Make Reed Likable. Pedro is charismatic and projects a friendly vibe.

15 hours ago
TheJack0fDiamonds
Scarlet Witch

Because the man can actually act. End of discussion. People are mad he was cast because their fancast didnt come true. Even when we got Karsinski as a nod for fan service in DS2 people still complained.

15 hours ago
wakarat

Regarding the mustache: This is a period piece. In the ‘60s, you didn’t get a lot of non-hippie/beatniks with beards, but a mustache wasn’t uncommon for someone of Reed’s social status. Maybe he will shave or grow a full beard when he’s brought to the present in later films.

14 hours ago
megalogo

I will wait to watch the movie to make an opinion

14 hours ago
BambooSound

I don't mind him in general but I was disappointed at the casting because it hinted at a more wholesome version of the Fantastic Four than I was hoping to see.

I was really excited by the idea of Jeremy Strong playing him but I knew it was never really likely.

14 hours ago
Rigged_Art

I like the points you made, especially about him fitting into the 60’s theme of the movie (everybody hates the mustache but it makes sense since having a mustache was extremely common back then) but I am still apprehensive because he isn’t known for roles like this mostly, he is a great actor but his filmography is very different from this movie, I do have faith

14 hours ago
Dlh2079

He's actor, he can pull off the look, and will definitely do a good job.

Thats really all that matters

We need to start ignoring and blocking these fuckin whiners.

14 hours ago
BrockOfTheFam

I mean he just doesn’t look like Reed in the majority of his appearances.

13 hours ago
black_metronome

Pedro is an amazing human being and talent. As a long time fan of Marvel Comics I think he is a great choice to play Reed.

13 hours ago
Hot_Effort9353

Pedro is a great actor, his acting in Last of Us was so subtle and real. Thank God is not John Krasinski, if you watch his last “adventure movie” from Apple, his acting stinks.

13 hours ago
Total-Astronomer-452

He fine

13 hours ago